Doom Wiki:RFC/Missing PWAD articles

From DoomWiki.org

< Doom Wiki:RFC
Revision as of 04:37, 14 February 2016 by MtErebus (talk | contribs) (Astrostein)

Edit-paste.svg

Request For Comment
This is an active request for comment on a particular article issue or project. Active RFCs are automatically logged at Doom Wiki:RFC and can be found in Category:Active RFCs.

RFC

The following PWAD articles are linked from the ZDoom Wiki and therefore count against us by being 404s:

  • Astrostein
  • Astrostein 2
  • Astrostein 3
  • Cheogsh
  • Cheogsh 2
  • Community Is Falling 3
  • Dark 7
  • Diaz
  • Doom Raider: Crypt of the Vile
  • Happy Time Circus
  • Khorus (WAD)
  • Project MSX
  • Real World
  • Temple of the Lizard Men 2
  • Tribute - This is not the best wad in the world
  • Unloved
  • Valhalla

Please prioritize creation of at least stub-quality articles for each of these after verifying their notability (almost all are Top 100 Wads or Cacoward winners/runners-up), and then either (if created) strike through the link in this list, or change the link to a {{deleted}} template so that it is not an active hyperlink.

Discussion

Astrostein mods

Notability seems pretty dubious.  Many people apparently thought they sucked, at least for gameplay (though the third was better).  We have precedent for putting a whole series into one article when they have a lot in common (Torment and Torture, 32in24).  Further opinions are welcome, but if I had to decide now, I'd redirect all three to WolfenDOOM (Doom).    Ryan W (talk) 20:58, 13 February 2016 (CST)

I would be OK with that. They could always be split off into their own articles if someone who's a fanatic about them has enough to say on their behalf. A redirect is a good interim until and unless such should happen. --Quasar (talk) 21:43, 13 February 2016 (CST)
Retrieved from "https://doomwiki.org/w/index.php?title=Doom_Wiki:RFC/Missing_PWAD_articles&oldid=109235"